The first time I saw them (The Musical Box) was in NYC about 3 years ago. I think it was the "Selling England by the Pound" tour, with the frontman doing Gabriel at his finest... costumes and all!!!
Got to see them again, at Westbury last Spring (2009) for the same "Trick of the Tail" tour as you just saw. Incredible show! One of the guys that played drums and sang actually looked like Phil Collins!
Would've loved to see them again this past Saturday, but had family commitments. Besides, I rather save my $$$ for their next tour and different music.
Friends of mine made fun of me paying that much $$$ to go see a "cover band", but they don't know what they're talking about! The "TOTT" show was only the second time that I've seen these guys, but I would say it's worth every penny to go.
SN