Over the years I tried just about everything under my CD player. I moved from Vibrapods, to cork squares, to cut in half squash balls, to home made rollerblocks, and pieces of hardwood. Each made a difference and should be looked at as a tuning device. There is no optimum answer for all systems. It just depends on what you think you are lacking and what effect a given material has on the sound, and they all have an effect.
Good luck in your quest, and try a bunch of things,
Bob