Bill,
Rather than ask permission to post any further replies to your original E-mail, why don't you give them a link to this thread and encourage them to register with AN themselves and get involved in this discussion first hand.
Tom
Excellent suggestion. Good topic BTW. For me the sound we grew up with was tubed. My Dad was not an audiophile but sold TVs and stereos back in the 50s and 60s. We had several tubed consoles. Listenmed to a lot of Sinatra, Count Basie and such. The sound was rich warm and dynamic. never thin or bright. So that was my reference growing up.
Many years later when I got in to this hobby by accident the sound I heardthat day at Stereo Exchange brought back found memories and that cozy feeling. The demo consisted of Apogee speakers and Counterpoint gear. A TT was used a Linn LP12 which I still have. We listened to some SS gear which did not float my boat at the time.
I guess I'm a tube man because that was my first experience in sound as a kid. Both SS and tubes have come a long way since my first audition in the 70s. Today either format gives me goosebumps. Go figure.
charles